Free shipping on orders over $49
Picky Pet Promise
Skip, change or cancel anytime
Questions? 1-855-981-8080
★★★★★
120,000+ verified 5-star reviews
Hay your rabbit actually finishes. Picked in the field by us. At your door before you run out.
Our 2nd cutting Timothy is soft, leafy and full of the flower heads bunnies dig for. We walk the fields ourselves, hand-pack every box, and ship it on a schedule so the hay bin is never empty.
How many rabbits are you feeding?
Hay Box for 1 rabbit
10 lb every 4 weeks
Hay Box for 1 rabbit
10 lb every 4 weeks
In your first box
Of hand-packed 2nd cutting Timothy hay, boxed, never compressed
Free bonus: A little surprise gift to make your first order extra special
Picky Pet Promise: if your rabbit won't eat it, we make it right
$ 34.99
$ 34.99
Picky Pet Promise
Ships same day by 4pm
Skip or cancel anytime
Hay Box for 1 rabbit
10% off your first 3 boxes
Checkout
Hay makes up about 80% of what your rabbit eats. It should be the best thing in the bowl.
Rabbits need a constant supply of long-strand fiber, every day, for life. So we obsess over the one food they eat the most of.
Even picky eaters dig in
Second cut is softer and leafier than first cut, with a medium amount of the flowery heads small animals go looking for. It smells like a field, and that smell is what gets a fussy bunny eating.
What to expect
A higher leaf-to-stem ratio than 1st cutting, so it's more fragrant and palatable
Plenty of crunchy sticks and flowery bits mixed through
Less left in the bin. As one owner of two bunnies put it: "they eat every last bit of it!"
Built for everyday gut and tooth health
Second cut Timothy is often called the gold standard for healthy adult small animals: the right balance of fiber for daily feeding, somewhere between the coarse 1st cut and the very soft 3rd.
What to expect
Long-strand fiber that supports healthy digestion
Natural chewing that helps wear down ever-growing teeth
Suitable for daily feeding for adult rabbits and guinea pigs
Hay you can smell the moment you open the box
We ship in a sturdy box, not a crushed bale. Stems and leaves arrive whole, green and fragrant, not as a bag of dust.
What to expect
Uncompressed, so leaves and flower heads stay intact
Mostly green, with some natural yellow or brown depending on the season's weather, which is normal and harmless
Hand-packed, every single box
You never run out again
Rabbits should never go without hay. Ever. Your plan ships on a schedule sized to how many bunnies you feed, so there's no late-night store run and no emergency bag of whatever's on the shelf.
What to expect
Order by 4pm PST and it ships the same day
Average delivery in under 2 business days
Change the size, skip a box or cancel from your account in a couple of clicks
Other brands have a lab. We have farmers we've known for 30 years.
Every summer we travel 22,500 miles through the fields of the Pacific Northwest. We see the crop, we smell it, and we only buy the hay we'd feed our own animals. These are the people who grow it.
“We know our fields, our crops, and what it takes to grow hay small pets love.”
“The right colour, a leafy texture, and that fresh hay smell. You can tell when a crop is grown and harvested with care.”
“They come back every summer. After all these years, they know our farms and we know what they expect.”
Why we do the driving ourselves
"Quality at the heart of everything we do.
Our passion at Small Pet Select is to provide the very best in natural, wholesome pet care. Every product we offer is either handmade or hand picked — a testament to our dedication to quality. From hay and bedding to toys and herbal blends, we refuse to accept anything other than the finest, most nutritious, and natural ingredients. This is our promise to you and your beloved pets."
Bill Gordon, CEO, Small Pet Select
What's different about a box from us
Most hay on store shelves is fine. It's just built for a warehouse, not for your rabbit.
Small Pet Select plan
Typical store-bought bag
Who picks it
Our team, in the field, every summer
Bought through a supply chain
How it's packed
Hand-packed in a sturdy box, uncompressed
Often compressed to save shipping space, which breaks up leaves
Getting it home
Arrives on a schedule, in under 2 business days on average
A trip to the store, and hoping it's in stock
Running out
Never, sized to your rabbits
Whenever you forget
If they won't eat it
Picky Pet Promise
It's yours now
22,500
miles we travel every summer to choose the hay
30+
years of relationships with Washington State farmers
2012
trusted by pet parents since
<2
business days average delivery
Reviewed by people who know small pets
A vet and two of the best-known small pet educators have put our hay to the test.
"We've been recommending Small Pet Select products for a long time."
Their focus on small pets and product quality makes Small Pet Select a brand worth exploring. Their review highlights the care taken in selecting hay and the reassurance offered by the Picky Pet Promise.
Guinea Piggles,
guinea pig care educators
"For most rabbits I recommend getting Second Cutting Timothy Hay from Small Pet Select."
Its softer texture and leafy blend make it a popular choice for everyday feeding. Amy Pratt also feeds it to her own rabbits, recommending 3rd Cutting Timothy Hay as an alternative for particularly picky rabbits who prefer softer hay.
Amy Pratt, The Bunny Lady,
lifelong rabbit owner who works with rabbits at the Humane Rescue Alliance
“Quality hay that passed our inspection with flying colors.”
The hay arrived in a colourful, decorative box that was fun to open. It looked fresh and green, with soft, leafy pieces packed generously into the box. The hay was clean, with minimal dust and very few coarse stems.
Dr. Stacie Grannum,
veterinarian, reviewing for Pet Keen
Real bunnies, real results
A few of our 120,000+ verified 5-star reviews.
Radar's story
Radar was a picky rabbit with some health issues, and getting enough fiber into him was a daily worry. His owner tried different types of hay, hoping to find one that would keep him interested and help make mealtime easier. Switching to fresher, tastier hay made all the difference. Soon, Radar was munching away more happily, making hay a more enjoyable part of his daily routine.
"Very green and fresh. Not dusty. Piggies love this hay. The best Timothy hay I've purchased."
Julie L., verified buyer
"Even my picky bunnies love this hay! I'm not buying any other! It comes in a sturdy box."
Tamera P., verified buyer
"Our 2 bunnies LOVE this hay! We will only buy from SPS as it never goes to waste, they eat every last bit of it!"
Maddie H., verified buyer
"I am caring for elderly rabbit… for the last year I've had nothing but stress and expense from trying to find some quality hay with ZERO success. … She jumped in box and tried it all with gusto!"
Andrea B., on our hay sampler box
"My bunnies love the second cutting Timothy hay! I love how it's packaged and how fast it ships. Best quality hay we've ever found!"
Kristen S., verified buyer
"I've tried several different brands, different hays (even hays from SPS) and 2nd cutting Timothy hay from Small Pet Select still reigns supreme in this house."
Andrea B., on our hay sampler box
"My bunny really likes this hay… Tried this second cut a couple times now and noticed the bunny is eating more of it."
Sandra S., verified buyer
"It's very fresh and has plenty of crunchy sticks and flowery bits. It comes well packed and ships quickly."
Caitlin S., verified buyer
The Never-Run-Out Hay Plan
Everything your rabbit needs from their main food, handled. Here's what you get when you start today.
10 lbof 2nd cutting Timothy hay
Hand-selected, hand-packed, boxed uncompressed
$34.99
Bonus: [First-box gift]
A little something extra to make your first delivery special.
Shipping
Free shipping on orders over $49. Average delivery in under 2 business days.
At checkout
Picky Pet Promise
If your rabbit won't eat it, we make it right
Included
Total value
$[XX]
$31.49
$34.99
If your rabbit won't eat it, it's on us.
[One sentence, one set of terms. Confirm: full refund or replacement? How many days? This must match the Picky Pet Promise help-centre page exactly.] No forms, no sending hay back. Just tell us.
Questions
Is 10 lb enough for one rabbit?
This content will be hidden until the user opens the collapsible. You can replace this content with whatever you feel should be hidden.
I have three rabbits, or guinea pigs too. Which plan?
This content will be hidden until the user opens the collapsible. You can replace this content with whatever you feel should be hidden.
What makes 2nd cutting different?
This content will be hidden until the user opens the collapsible. You can replace this content with whatever you feel should be hidden.
My rabbit is picky. Will they eat it?
This content will be hidden until the user opens the collapsible. You can replace this content with whatever you feel should be hidden.
Some of my hay has brown pieces. Is that OK?
This content will be hidden until the user opens the collapsible. You can replace this content with whatever you feel should be hidden.
How do I skip, change or cancel?
This content will be hidden until the user opens the collapsible. You can replace this content with whatever you feel should be hidden.
How should I store it?
This content will be hidden until the user opens the collapsible. You can replace this content with whatever you feel should be hidden.
Give them hay worth finishing.
Pick your plan, and the hay bin stays full from here on. Covered by the Picky Pet Promise.
By selecting Auto-Ship, you are signing up for recurring deliveries and agree to our Auto-Ship Terms, Conditions & Cancelation Policy. Eligible orders are backed by our Picky Pet Promise; see Policy Exceptions. Offer valid for new Auto-Ship customers only.
Veterinary Disclaimer. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat or cure any condition. Consult your vet about your pet's diet.
© 2026 Small Pet Select U.S.
